Northern Virginia Realtors

CMA, List Price, Sold price, Appraised Value. Help! What does it all mean?

Corolla NCBob: What is the difference between list price, sales price and appraised value? I want a thorough and long answer please. I am thinking about buying a home soon.

Steve: Bob, the list price is the seller's current advertised price for his property. The price that the seller sets could be at, above or below the property's market value.





Corolla NC

In a buyer’s market, when prices are flat and/or falling and there's a lot of housing inventory available, you could reasonably expect to offer at or below the market value.

Bob: How does the agent figure out the market value? Can’t we just go with what that really popular online estimating website says?






Wild horses in Corolla NC. Outer BanksSteve: Bob, the market value of your home of interest should be determined by your agent who will analyze the prices of recently sold comparable properties near that home, using what should be the “net” prices received by the sellers of those homes used for comparison.

By “net” price, I mean that any seller’s subsidy or monetary help the buyer receives back from the seller should be subtracted from the published sales price of properties being used for comparison.


 For example, if a comparable home sold for a sales price of $350,000 with the seller paying $10,000 of the buyer’s closing costs, the net sales price of that home is $340,000 not $350,000. Your real estate agent should be able to obtain and compile this data for you. It is a major part of her job.

 Wild horses in Corolla NC. Outer Banks
Do not rely on those auto generated online estimator programs or the like, they are notoriously prone to error because those folks may not be using the most current data and they cannot make adjustments for improperly recorded square footage in the tax records or listings, or the updates and condition of the subject properties.




In a tight market, every $5,000 makes a huge difference to you as buyer, and in our experience that is the closest that the public national programs can do…. usually they are more prone to error than that.


Corolla NC


Bob: I have heard the acronym CMA. What does that mean?


Steve:  It is a home pricing analysis tool that your agent should use to provide you with data you will use to determine your offer price.

It stands for Comparative Market Analysis. There is a CMA that most agents can compile from the local MLS in a relatively short period of time. These are very good for getting a “close” approximation of market value to use in comparing your homes of interest.

 Currituck Lighthouse Corolla NC

However,when you get down to writing an offer, if the properties that are being used as comparables are very different in style, lot size and square footage (this is often the case), the standard CMA may not be good enough.


Your agent should have the ability to do a spread sheet analysis using square footage records obtained from the tax records (which are often inaccurate and must be adjusted by experience) as well as provide you with a ratio of sold price to tax assessed value for all the properties being  evaluated for comparison with the home you are offering on.




This can take hours for her to prepare since the data does not auto load from the county's tax records and everything needs to be double checked for accuracy.

Corolla NC soundside


Once this is done, you will then be able to see what homes in the neighborhood have been selling for on a square footage basis as well as see how the net sales price to tax assessed ratio lays out for all the properties used in comparison.

With this data at your disposal, you as  buyer will be well armed for negotiations.




Bob: Man, that’s a lot to remember.



  Corolla NC outer banks.

Steve: Bob, don’t sweat it…experienced agents know how to do this.

In fact when you interview prospective buyer's agents you may want to ask them to show you an example of a spread sheet analysis they have done for previous buyers.


As far as the last part of your original question regarding appraised value…..the appraised value is a certified appraiser's estimate of the worth of a property, and is based on comparable sales,  condition of the property, square footage and numerous other somewhat “subjective” factors.

Corolla NC soundsideIt is the basis for the mortgage lender’s valuation of the property and determines in large part what they will lend on a particular home.


Bob: That was pretty thorough.


Steve: Thanks Bob, when you actually see a detailed CMA you will be pleased..they are very cool and easy to understand.



Why pay more and get less when selling your home? Jan and Steve Bachman of RE/MAX Gateway use professional photographers, create interactive photo floor plans, print full color brochures, and make an individual property website for your listing that goes out to 40+ public real estate search sites including, Trulia, Zillow etc.


We also create a custom photo tour that is sent to other agents and prospective buyers.



RE/MAX Hall of Fame, Platinum Club, A Washingtonian Magazine Top Agent 2018

Happy to Help. No Hassle, No Pressure.

Jan and Steve Bachman are full time Realtors® with RE/MAX, specializing in Homes for Sale in Fairfax, Loudoun, Prince William and Arlington Counties.



Our 3 rescue dogs have been GREAT! Go get a couple.

Comment balloon 9 commentsSteve and Jan Bachman • August 10 2010 07:01PM
CMA, List Price, Sold price, Appraised Value. Help! What does it all…
Bob: What is the difference between list price, sales price and appraised value? I want a thorough and long answer please. I am thinking about buying a home soon. Steve: Bob, the list price is the seller's current advertised price for his… more
Foreclosures in Chantilly, Herndon, and Reston VA. August 10, 2010…
Foreclosure properties listed for sale in Chantilly, Herndon and Reston VA. Bank owned REOs. You may have heard that all Foreclosed properties are in such bad shape and so disgusting, that you should not consider them as a viable option for… more
Foreclosure properties for sale in Reston, Herndon, and Sterling VA…
Foreclosure properties for sale in Reston, Herndon, and Sterling VA. REOs If you have heard that bank owned foreclosed properties are… more
Should I Rent or Should I Buy?
Should I Rent or Should I Buy? Tom: I want to buy a home but I'm pretty cautious about the whole thing. Is real estate still a good investment or is renting a better idea? Steve: If you want to buy a home and try to sell… more
Can you show me homes in Penderbrook? And how do those lock boxes…
Can you show me homes in Penderbrook, Fairfax? Oh and and how do those lock boxes work? This is a SentriLock Realtor’s lock box How Do Realtors Get INTO HOUSES? (How stuff works in Realtorland) Tammy: My… more
Buying a home in Northern Virginia? Making sense of the tax credits…
Tom: We plan to buy a home in Northern Virginia. It will be our first one. I have to say that it is hard to keep track of all the opinions regarding the future of mortgage interest rates and the various tax credit… more
Video:Home Buyer Tax Credit plus Access a Great Homes for Sale Search…
Just a quick update for those of you who might be considering a Reston or Herndon home purchase over the next several months. The IRS is providing a tax credit to first-time home buyers and also to those… more
Home Buyer tax credit extension for extended duty military and…
One year Home buyer Tax Credit extension for Extended Duty Military and Foreign Service Personnel. Short Video below. Good news from the IRS! Now there's an oxymoron… but here is a rule change that makes sense. According to the video, qualified… more
Home buyer tax credit forms. Link to the IRS site… better yet hire a…
If you have purchased a home in 2009 and have not yet filed your taxes, we encourage you to consult a tax professional. There are tax advantages that you may not be aware of if you have not owned before. In addition to the interest you pay each… more
Foreclosure Auctions on the Courthouse Steps: Can I play? Episode 2.
It was another freezing day at the county courthouse, standing outside to bid at the trustee sale of properties that have defaulted on their mortgages(foreclosure sales) 12 properties were on the original docket… 4 had been removed from the… more